In
so many ways, Mark Janus is a very fortunate man. He works for a state agency
in Illinois—the same state that has nearly bankrupted itself
gifting employees like Mr. Janus with plump, well-fed pensions.
But
that's not enough. Our poor, put-upon Mr. Janus has his knickers in a
twist because he has to pay $45 a month in union dues for his
membership in AFSCME.
As
a dyed-in-the-wool conservative, Mr. Janus feels he should keep
everything he makes. He feels he shouldn't have to pay taxes and fees
and especially union dues, which is certainly interesting given the
talking points his political party of choice likes to trot out.
Mark
Janus should get his sewage treated, meat inspected, roads repaired
and libraries stocked and staffed (not to mention his union
representation) for free, but god forbid the poor, the disabled and
the elderly get help with, well, just about anything.
Because
that would make them freeloaders.
But
conservatives like Mr. Janus aren't.
Got it?
In
the words of Mr. Janus' lawyer, “AFSCME takes political positions
that he doesn't support and advocates for more spending and higher
taxes.”
I
would like to invite Mr. Janus to work in the private sector, where
after airing his complaint he would be told that thanks to the
miracle of At Will employment, he was free to leave.
Of
course, Mr. Janus would never leave his public-sector job because that
would mean giving up his union-negotiated salary, union-negotiated
benefits and that oh-so-sweet union-negotiated pension.
Yes,
Mr. Janus wants his cake and a big, giant fork.
And
to be honest, so do I.
I
can only dream of not paying
taxes to the circus headed by Donald Trump and what I call
Republicants because they stand for nothing I believe in and
everything I don't. But if I want to enjoy the benefits of living in
America, taxes must be paid.
Of
course, this is much, much bigger than Mr. Janus and his
wallet-busting union dues. It's about defunding unions and
consequently, Democrats. It's about the tragically mis-labeled Right
to Work statute.
Because
in the addled logic of right-wingers like Mr. Janus, Democrats and
unions are the enemy. Even as they provide a secure and
comfortable living for him.
One
party rule is clearly the best path forward because even as Mr. Janus
rails against the effects of prolonged one-party rule in Illinois,
Republicans controlling everything forever would somehow be
different.
This
because businessmen would be running things.
Perhaps
you know how great things were the last time wealthy businessmen were
in control. The salad days of the late nineteenth-century. The
Industrial Revolution.
Employment
was so abundant men worked six days a week, for ten, eleven and
twelve hours a day. And not just men. No sir. Those free-thinking, egalitarian businessmen opened up their factories to everyone. Even
kids.
And
thanks to their generous wages, upward mobility was never more
prevalent. Frugal, industrious folk could save enough cash to have
stew—with meat—once a week. Or dream of a visit to a cobbler and
a new pair of shoes. Or buy a coffin for ma when she died during
childbirth.
Yes,
life was grand.
Then
those goddamn Democrats and their confounded unions screwed
everything up.
Thanks
to their unswerving dedication to make life better for everyone (i.e.
even people who didn't possess millions of dollars), people could not
work seventy hours a week and still have a shot at living quarters
that included light, fresh air, indoor plumbing and electricity.
They
could even afford to see doctors before they died at forty-five of
black lung or tuberculosis or dysentery.
But
as the best and the brightest conservative minds have pointed out,
this sucked.
It
sucked because unlike you and me, the folks organizing labor and
effectively fighting the offal in the executive wing for a fair share
of corporate profits needed money to live. This is where the heresy
of union dues enters the picture.
And
if that weren't bad enough, some wise-ass got the idea for an urban
sewage system. And another for consumer protections. And yet another
for an agency that would promote public health.
And
boom! We had taxes.
You
have to agree this was pointless, wasteful stuff.
Through
the widespread implementation of Right to Work statutes, we can—at long last—cede
control to Republicans and their healthy, inclusive,
we're-all-in-this-together agenda.
Anger
is a very unhealthy state of being. It's what makes us cut off our
nose to spite our face. It's what makes bloggers post inarticulate
rants—like I did last Thursday. When we're angry our thinking is
muddled. Our actions lamentable.
Do
we really want to destroy unions? Do we really want to remove the
checks-and-balances a two party system provides? Do we really want to
hand over one-hundred percent of everything to Republicans and
wealthy businessmen?
Are
we really so naive?
So
many things in the United States of America could be better. Our
leadership. Our government. Ourselves. But throwing the baby out with
the bathwater isn't the answer.
We
don't burn down our houses when we discover an insect infestation. We
call an exterminator. And despite my howling indignation about so
many facets of twenty-first century America, I don't generally
advocate for revolution.
Yeah,
blowing stuff up and smashing windows is lots of fun. And who doesn't
enjoy a roaring fire now and then? But in the end it mostly wastes
time and energy. And the clean-up is a bitch.
Mr.
Janus, the vast majority of taxes go to the public good, except in
places like Illinois where the *ahem* pension obligation threatens the
economic well-being of the entire state and demands an inordinate share of tax revenue.
Whining about higher taxes
and political positions as your employer slavishly seeks to honor its
pension commitment to you is questionable at best and off-the-charts hypocrisy at worst. Now would be a good time to mention that Janus was a two-faced Roman god.
Tell you what, Janus. Why don't you file a suit alleging your pension is too generous, and that instead of threatening the entire population with higher taxes and service cuts, your employer should instead increase your union dues and scale back your benefits?
You know, show some of that individual responsibility you Republicans are always crowing about.
Yeah. That's what I thought.